MxMo XXXIX: Amaro, a Dog’s Tale
Bitters, Call to Arms, Drinkage, Nerd Gadabout, Rye May 20th, 2009
I’m late for Mixology Monday, it’s true. Though rather than blame it on a dog eating my homework or, rather, drinking it, allow me to blame it on a certain dog in San Francisco who inspired me to chase its tail in the recreation of this drink. This is a tale of a weary traveler, who after long nights in bars, long days in distilleries, and sampling many fine brandies and Eau de Vies, was left in Oakland and drifted back to the other side of the Bay one Sunday afternoon looking for respite. Walking aimlessly around Union Square, drifting by noted liquor stores and finding them cruelly closed and, parched and listless, glancing at the San Francisco Museum of Modern Art, and grimacing at the slice of life observed at 6th and Mission, I found my oasis, Heaven’s Dog. And, just as it opened.
Heaven’s Dog’s bar is constructed from a single cut of wood from a white cedar tree and the blend of contemporary and natural elements strikes you as you sit and face a long string of delights, spaced evenly and uncluttered behind the bartender, and contemplate what joys may come. Erik, it so happens, was part of the Feng shui on this visit. Heaven’s Dog features a “Freedom from Choice” on its menu and, in my deprived state, I was in need of such freedom. I glared at the bottles along the wall and, seeing Amaro Nonino, told Erik, “Something using Amaro Nonino, but dry, crisp, and refreshing.” Erik passed me my glass of water and, my trust and palate in his hands, went to work. This, as best as I can work out33 , is what I was served:
Upward Dog
- 2oz Rye whiskey
- .75oz Dry vermouth
- .75oz Amaro Nonino (used Amaro Meletti at home in the recreation of it)
- 2 barspoons Maraschino liqueur
Stir and strain. Serve with a lemon twist.
This is a delightful drink. I always develop crushes on simple and classically-styled cocktails that come across well-constructed and deliver complex and pleasing results. The balance of amaro against the rye and dry vermouth avoids the overly earthy or perfumey quality many amaro-heavy drinks acquire and the maraschino liqueur adds a sweet nutty touch without creating too much body. I highly recommend this and, if you can’t get Amaro Nonino, use a brighter and spicier amaro in your arsenal as a sub. Amaro Meletti is very light-bodied and brings a brightness to this that is most enjoyable. I also recommend using a drier rye than Old Overholt or Russell’s Reserve. Something on the order of Rittenhouse Bonded or Sazerac 6-year is called for here.
Heaven’s Dog assembles an incredible array of talent behind its bar. Erik Adkins, Thad Vogler, Erik Ellestad, and the other notable bartenders behind the stick represent a repository of cocktail knowledge and sound mixological principles that should be recognized and appreciated by the cocktailians of San Francisco. While Heaven’s Dog’s cocktail menu is squarely centered on vintage cocktails with a focus on local and natural ingredients, any bar where a patron can ask for a “Freedom from Choice” and have J. Wray Nephew Overproof rum as the called spirit and have delivered such a delightful cocktail as Thad managed, on the fly, to create deserves not only our respect but a bit of our awe as well.
I highly recommend the Bumblebee and Pisco Apricot Tropical. Or, if Ellestad is behind the stick, the Upward Dog.
Upward Dog Rating: 




3
- and with the help of Erik333
3







What an icredibly wonderful photo Gabe!
I wish i had the ingredients to make it.
T
Big fan of Maraschino with rye, especially in Manhattan. I must try this drink. I don’t have nonino or meletti and also don’t know their taste. Damn space considerations of city living. What other amaros are also similar to nonino, if any? Not sure I know what brighter means.
Wow – this is exactly the same as a drink I have been making for a few months now. Sort of a variation on the Brooklyn cocktail. Tasty beverage there! I first read about this general cocktail here…
http://cocktailbuzz.blogspot.com/2008/08/mixology-monday-its-brooklyn-thing.html...
…but I mix mine closer to your ratio. I should try it with a higher end Rye, but sadly the low low price of Old Overholt keeps me coming back.
Having come to something similar on my own at home (I use slightly less of each of the non-rye ingredients), I must point out that this is markedly different with Nonino than it is with Meletti. (There’s a faint banana note with the Nonino.)
Whoa that cocktail looks really tasty.. I myself like Dirty Martini’s and found this recipe online for it http://www.howcast.com/videos/90-How-To-Make-a-Dirty-Martini People think i’m nuts but I love the taste of olives and vodka.
I guess I’m a barbarian for ordering Manhattans even without vermouth. My favorite mixer has always been my bloodstream.
Just the same, love how you wrap narrative around review here. I’m a fan.
Cheers.
Lovely, I can’t wait to try this, but will need to get some maraschino first. I’d second the request for more information on the relative merits of different Amaro. I’ve got Averna and Fernet on the shelf but could find the excuse to spring for a new one if needed.
I’m guessing you know the Toronto already? This drink seems like a riff on it, the first thing that comes to mind for me when I think of mixing rye and amaro.
Here’s a recipe – http://spiritsandcocktails.wordpress.com/2006/11/21/toronto-cocktail/
Ok, I’ve bought the Amaro Meletti (haven’t been able to get my hands on Amaro Nonion yet) and the Maraschino, yes, this is a great drink. I could definitely see the Amaro Nonino making a difference, and now I have another cocktail I want to try it in, so I will need to track some down.
Oh, and that other cocktail? It’s stunning. A combo of 2 pts. light rum (Mt. Gay was used), 1 part Amaro Nonino, and 1 pt. Oloroso Sherry. Was in NYC for a minute the other night and ended up at the bar at Gramercy Tavery having a drink and talking with the guy next to me, who turned out to be pretty sharp on this stuff. Following your gambit, I saw Nonino behind the bar and asked the bartender if he had any good ideas for Nonino cocktails. Turned out the guy next to me knew Amaros up and down and suggested this combination, which he first had at a bar in Ginza, Japan, to the bartender. Man was it good, and in a certain sense, all thanks to this post, which got me obsessed with Nonino.
So yeah, now I need some Nonino and an Oloroso Sherry.
[...] was introduced to the Bumblebee by the fine work they do at Heaven’s Dog in San Francisco and love this drink when the seasons change between summer and fall. Using an aged [...]
My first drink made with my first bottle of Amaro Nonino. You may not be pleased to learn I went to Paul’s blog first to find a recipe, but perhaps the fact that I chose your recipe will mitigate that sadness.
I’ve never been a huge fan of rye + dry vermouth, but this cocktail has changed my mind. It’s almost like a Martinez.
Cheers sir!